If you ever saw the documentary “Black Sheep” starring Chris Farley and David Spade, you know what I’m on about. In that film, Farley portrays a bumbling, not very bright younger brother to a gubernatorial candidate. Farley gets shipped off to the woods for the campaign so he won’t embarrass his brother, and Spade is put on babysitting duty. Hijinks, of course, ensue.
Far too many trout anglers treat whitefish just like Farley was treated by his brother—as the black sheep of the family. The fish to be ignored, the fish that, because it looks a little different, has been relegated to a lower tier of society. I thought we fly anglers were far more progressive and forward-thinking than that, right? We’re inclusive and want folks to feel welcome on the water, but we openly hate on one of the West’s most important native fish?
That’s the epitome of hypocrisy.
Get To Know The Whitefish
The Mountain Whitefish (Prosopium williamsoni) is a proud member of the salmonid family—the same family home to salmon, trout, char, and grayling. They’re cylindrical in shape, with a forked tail, large adipose fin, rough scales, and a small, downturned mouth. That mouth looks similar to bottom-feeding fish like suckers and chub, and since whitefish are often caught using the same flies we use for trout, they historically gained a reputation as a fish that was “out-competing” more aesthetically pleasing trout like brookies.
Whitefish are native to the McKenzie River drainage in Canada, some Hudson Bay drainages, all the way down to the Missouri River headwaters, and as far south as the Capitol Reef area of southern Utah.
Whitefish Behavior
With their downturned mouth, whitefish are often labeled bottom-feeders. That’s not strictly true, since whitefish don’t dine on plants and wood fiber like true bottom-feeding fish do. Instead, whitefish are primarily predators of aquatic insects—just like trout.
Whitefish will stir up the substrate on a riverbed to expose aquatic insects for quick, easy snacking. When they grow larger, they’ve been known to eat crawdads. They’ll also rise to take dry flies off the surface in especially thick hatches. That sounds just like another popular gamefish us anglers love to chase…
You’ll typically find whitefish in deeper runs and pools in rivers, often hugging the bottom. They tend to roam in large groups, so where you catch one, you’re likely to catch at least a few more. And this is where I think the whitefish really struts its stuff.
Better Than Trout?
My best fishing buddy isn’t fond of whitefish, and it stems from the fact that, when you first start catching them, they feel like large trout. Whitefish don’t jump; instead, they stay low—where you hooked them—and go on rod-shuddering runs. The term “bulldogging” gets used to describe how big fish just take your fly and run, and that’s exactly what whitefish do.
What’ll really surprise you is you’ll think you have an 18-inch trout on the line, only to net a 14-inch whitefish. They fight much harder than most trout of a similar size. After you’ve caught a few whitefish, you can start to feel the differences in how they fight compared to trout. You’ll know in a few seconds whether you have a trout or whitefish on the line.
Personally, I wouldn’t characterize their fights as “better” than what you get from a trout. It’s different, in the same way that trout themselves are different. Lake trout, for instance, go on long, drag-burning runs. Rainbows tend to be more acrobatic. Whitefish definitely have a spastic energy to them, paired with a lot of rolling. They’re excellent at tangling up tandem nymph rigs when you have them in the net.
On the plus side, since whitefish have tiny, essentially toothless mouths, hooks pop free with less effort than trout. And, you won’t go through flies at an insane rate, either. Whitefish don’t have large enough teeth to tear and rip apart the flies you either paid a lot for, or spent time tying. That’s downright considerate of the whitefish, in my book.
Native and Abundant
Most anglers I know love cutthroat trout, or at the very least, admire them. I’ve yet to meet someone who looks down on rainbows, especially those caught from their native range in Pacific Ocean drainages. The same goes for bull trout and goldens.
Whitefish are one of the few native fish here in the West that aren’t confined to only a fraction of their historical native range. Shoot, in some places I like to fish, whitefish outnumber trout in certain stretches. The opportunity to go catch native fish isn’t something we take for granted as anglers, but when it comes to whitefish, the general consensus is that, sure, they’re native, but they’re not a trout.
And that’s the crux of the matter, isn’t it? Trout are so often the grand prize in fly fishing, even though the world of fly fishing has long since expanded beyond the realm of an old guy in tweed, smoking a pipe, and fishing dry flies on a downstream drift.
Bonefish have made a good name for themselves, and even carp are popular. I don’t like carp or carp fishing, for the record, but I’ll freely admit that they’re objectively a unique, challenging fish to chase with a fly rod. So why are whitefish maligned? Outcast? The black sheep of the trout family?
I think it all boils down to the fact that they behave like trout, and live next to trout, but they’re not trout, and that spoils the picture some anglers paint in their mind of what a day of fly fishing is meant to be. We all have our own ideals, and there’s no shame in that. But there needs to be a willingness to consider that maybe, just maybe, this long-held belief that whitefish are somehow less-than is just incorrect.
They’re spunky. They fight well. They’re native and not on the chopping block like cutthroat or bull trout. The big ones are tough to catch, and they’re often the first fish to save your day from a skunk.
If nothing else, they deserve our love for their willingness to eat a bit of fur and feathers wrapped around a hook.

I would like to mention that smoked whitefish, like those I meat-fished every winter on the Elk River in Steamboat Springs, are simply delicious. And fun to catch.