Are Waders Worth The Cost?

I’ve absolutely had it with waders. Of all the fly fishing gear an angler can sink money into, these are the biggest pit. They’re a product you buy with the full knowledge that, eventually, they will fail. You’ll throw these away at some point. Unlike a high-end fly rod (which has a level of craftsmanship and attention to detail waders never will), a $1,000 pair of waders isn’t something you can hand down to your kids.

For at least a decade, I’ve subscribed to the notion that if you want waders that will last a long time—and have the best warranty—then you need to spend a good chunk of change. That was my experience when I finally bought a pair of Simms G4 waders, the first high-end waders I owned. Those waders held up well through nearly four years of abuse, including a couple of years when I put more than 100 days on the water. Eventually, they sprung a leak along the rear leg seam, so I sent them in for warranty work.

That’s the last pair of high-end waders I’ve had hold up for more than two seasons of consistent use.

Bad Luck, Or Just Bad Products?

It’s entirely possible I’m just on a generational run of bad luck with waders. In my job as Gear Editor, though, I’ve had the chance to review, wear, and test an awful lot of waders over the last decade. Most of those waders are worn for 2-3 months, then hung up in my closet. My favorite pairs see consistent use, but even then, I’m testing and reviewing new pairs often enough that it’s rare for a pair to get more than 20-30 days of use per year. Combine that with how much I wet wade, and I’m in waders for a relatively small number of my fishing days.

Which is why I find it hard to believe that I’m alone in experiencing a relatively high rate of wader failure, across all the brands. In just the past three years, I’ve returned two pairs of waders for leaky seams. One pair was sent back for the left neoprene bootie falling apart. Another pair saw two seams burst simultaneously, which the wader company told me was my fault because I’d picked the wrong size.

That’s four pairs of expensive waders, in less than a half-decade, that haven’t held up to little more than enough use for a review.

Meanwhile, I have a couple of fishing buddies who haven’t had to buy new waders in five or six years. Sure, theirs have some pinhole leaks patched with Aquaseal, but the seams are tight, and the waders are still doing their job.

Fit And Care

Now, I know I’m the common denominator in this experience with waders. But I have a close fishing buddy who has been through the same wringer—three pairs in two years. All the problems were manufacturing defects.

The easy thing to point to here is that I’m not taking care of my waders correctly. For sure, that was a problem early on in my fishing days. But I like to think I’ve gotten a bit less lazy in my old age. I hang my waders to dry after every trip. They don’t spend time wadded up in my truck bed, and I’ll even bring them in and hang them in the lodge or hotel when I’m on longer multi-day trips. I’ve started going out of my way to keep them hung up, well-ventilated (to prevent mildew growth, which is a big killer of the technology used to weld wader seams together), and clean.

I have a twice-yearly wader washing party, where I scrub them by hand and re-apply a DWR spray.

On top of that, I’ve tried to pay careful attention to fit. If your waders don’t fit well, you’ll put more stress on the seams. That’s one of the easiest ways to quickly blow through waders, and I don’t think fit is the problem, either.

I think we’ve just been conditioned to expect too much of our waders.

What Are You Actually Paying For?

The prevailing wisdom with waders for as long as I’ve been fishing is that the cheap ones you buy at big-box stores won’t last long and won’t be comfortable. The expensive ones that only fly shops carry should last longer, and they at least come with a warranty that will fix or replace the waders (although that still leaves you without a pair when they break down).

I do need to give a shout-out to most wader companies, though. With the exception of one that’s no longer in business, I’ve had nothing but great experiences with the warranty and repair departments are various wader makers. The perk of paying up for expensive waders is that you essentially get wader insurance. If they fail or don’t perform, the company will usually replace or repair them. If they’re not repairable, you’ll often get a new pair of waders either free or at a significantly reduced cost. So while the waders themselves still pose durability questions, the companies are doing a good job of taking care of customers who are shelling out that cash.

When a wader company wants more than $900 for waders, though, what are you paying for at that point? Is that $900 pair of waders really going to last that much longer than waders priced at $250? Shoot, you can spend $1,100 now on waders from one of the big-name companies. At that price point, I’d want my waders to help net my fish.

Sure, the materials on these more expensive waders are nicer. There are usually more options for dialing in a better fit, and you get more pockets and features. But none of that matters if you’re shopping for waders again in two years. That’s been my experience far too often lately.

Products are supposed to improve over time. With each new wader release, we’re told that these are the latest-and-greatest, that they have some fancy anti-puncture technology, or the fabric has been “proven” to be more durable than the last iteration. I’d wager I’m not the only one who feels like this is all marketing mumbo-jumbo. What’s promised and what’s delivered are two different things when it comes to my experience with waders.

But I’m just one data point in this conversation. I’d love to hear from you. How has your experience been with waders? Have you found the high-end products to be worth the money? Or are you as frustrated as I am? Sound off in the comments.

Spencer Durrant
Spencer Durrant
Spencer Durrant has worked in fly fishing media for over a decade. He's had bylines in Field & Stream, Gray's Sporting Journal, MidCurrent, Hatch Magazine, and numerous other publications. He's also the host of the weekly podcast Untangled: Fly Fishing for Everyone. Spencer lives in Wyoming with his wife and two papillons.
Categories

Similar Articles

Comments

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles