Don’t Overlook the “Off-Season”

Presented by Gunnison Crested Butte Tourism

Being an angler in the West has its perks. Plenty of water is worth fishing, access is abundant, and there are relatively few seasonal closures aside from heat restrictions and spawning closures. Not to mention, here in the great state of Colorado, we’re so close to the sun that even when the weather turns, it’s typically not for long. The clouds burn off easily, and even on snowy days, you can fare fine in a short-sleeve shirt. Nonetheless, many anglers consider the months after September the off-season.

Now, most of the anglers I’m referring to fly in from the neighboring states of Texas and California and believe fly fishing is a spring sport. It might be because weather becomes too much of a variable in their travel plans, or they just haven’t discovered the latest trend in staying warm (layering). Whatever the reason, it’s such a trend that plenty of lodges and guide outfits call it quits and close their doors until the warmer months. But for those that stay open, diehard anglers can find excellent and overlooked opportunities this off-season. Don’t take our word for it, though; here are four reasons that prove the off-season is the best time of year to fish.

1. Avoid the Crowds:

We had the opportunity to head out to Gunnison County this October (a particularly dreary and rainy one, as a matter of fact), and when I say we didn’t see a soul on the water, I mean it. And I know what you’re thinking already: “Well, now that you’re telling everyone about this secret, the rivers are going to be packed!” No, they’re not. See, that’s the beauty of some rain and a cold spell. It pushes all those fair-weather weekend warriors deep inside their comfortable boxes, regardless of this article’s existence. 

You can find solitude on many of the busiest Western rivers come fall.

Another factor that keeps crowds at bay during this time is other opportunities and obligations. Especially here in Colorado, most hardcore sportspeople spend the fall exploring the rolling mountain ranges in search of Elk. Others, like me, chase birds. Plenty, when the cold months really roll around, get so caught up in going up and down a snowy hill that they forget fishing exists altogether. Regardless of the reason, if you’re looking for peace and quiet, the off-season offers abundant solitude.

2. Exciting Fishing Opportunities

As the seasons change, fall ushers in a variety of new fishing opportunities. Beginning in late September and early October, brown trout switch to their pre-spawn patterns. This makes them far more aggressive in their pursuit of food and territory, which behooves anglers willing to put in some time. Mix this newfound aggression with some dreary weather and cloud cover, and you’ve got a streamer day for the ages! 

Do note, it’s extremely important to know the difference between pre-spawn and spawn. Once these fish take to their nests (or redds), it’s time to move on. Harassing spawning fish might seem like a cheat code, but it’s a great way to mess up your fishery fast, since these fish have a job to do, and getting hooked in the face really messes it up. A great rule of thumb for fishing this time of year is that: if you don’t know, don’t guess. If it looks like a nest or a spawning fish, then it probably is. 

This time, however, is a great opportunity to tie on some egg patterns and target some cohabitual trout species like rainbows, which spawn in the spring. During this time, these fish are gorging themselves on eggs and will key in quicker than ever to a little ball of antron yarn.

Kokanee salmon and other angling opportunities are only available in the fall.

In addition to trout, kokanee salmon also make a run through many rivers in Gunnison County during this time of year. Occupying the depths of reservoirs such as Blue Mesa, these salmon were planted here almost a century ago. Many speculate this was to give locals new sources of harvestable subsistence. These days, they’re more of a treat for sporting folks looking for exciting new catch-and-release opportunities. 

If you catch them early enough, these fish will take anything colorful or shiny you put in front of them and will put a 5-weight to the test with an impressive display of runs and aerial acrobatics. To find them, look for deep pools behind well-oxygenated riffles. You can often find them sharing a run with the local trout population.

3. Cost Saving Opportunities

This might be the best reason to hedge your bets on the “off-season”. For many of us these days, money is tight. And while most of us are willing to disobey our better judgment and go deep into debt for the chance to fish the West, fishing outside key travel windows can certainly save us a much-needed buck. Whether it’s hotels trying to capitalize on fleeting tourism dollars or airlines seeing a lower surge in bookings, opportunists can often find a room or flight at half the cost of peak season. 

For anglers looking to save money, fall off-season can be the best time to book.

With this advantage come sacrifices you should be prepared to make. The off-season can also mean some places, including lodges and restaurants, may already be closed. It can also come with more erratic weather conditions, as mentioned above. This shouldn’t discourage travelers from using these seasonal windows to explore, but it should encourage them to double-check that their favorite tourist attraction is still open before planning a visit.

4. Guide availability

Lastly, for those who like to fish with a guide when they travel (which we highly encourage), during this time of year, guides are typically pretty available. Many are winding down their seasons and prepping for winter, but if you find willing souls who aren’t transitioning to ski season just yet, some of the best help on the water becomes available during these periods. This includes those who are typically booked every day of the week during peak season.

As fishing winds down, off-season can be a great time to book with the best guides on the water.

During our stay this fall, we had the opportunity to fish with some of the amazing guides from Harmels on the Taylor. We want to give a big shout-out to them for accommodating us in some very cozy cabins (a perfect place to wait out a rainy off-season morning) and linking us up with some of their best guides, including John Evon, who did a bang-up job showing us around the county. (Check them out HERE).

Plan for the Off-Season

I know many anglers who live in these areas will scoff at the idea of hanging up their waders come October. However, when I asked family, friends, and peers, I was shocked to learn how many anglers view this seasonal window as a time to stay home. So, if you’re hoping to squeeze the last bit of juice out of your year, check out some flights, cash in some PTO, and make your way to a place you may have never been before. Life’s short, and you can’t catch fish from your couch! 

Please consider: if you are planning to head somewhere new to fish during this time, make sure you’re familiar with fishing regs, as they vary greatly by state, county, and even body of water. For Colorado, you can find local regulations HERE. Fish responsibly, pick up your trash, and remember: we’re all in this together. 

Thanks to Gunnison Crested Butte for making this guide possible. For more information on fishing in Gunnison County, click HERE.

Wills Donaldson
Wills Donaldson
Wills is a homegrown Pennsylvania Fly Fisherman and is the Director of Brand Partnerships here at Flylords. Since he was young, Wills enjoyed spending his summers journeying through the remote wilderness of Ontario and Quebec via wood canvas canoe. He has always felt a magnetic pull to the water, and can oftentimes be found still casting at rising trout deep into the night.

Similar Articles

Comments

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles